Judge Refuses to Dismiss DRAM Supply Collusion Lawsuit

A California judge refused to dismiss a class-action lawsuit accusing Samsung, SK hynix and Micron of coordinating to restrict conventional DRAM supply, keeping the case on track for discovery.

Share
DRAM chip wafer close-up

A California federal judge refused to dismiss a class-action lawsuit accusing Samsung, SK hynix and Micron of coordinating to restrict supply of conventional DRAM chips. The ruling keeps the case on track for discovery, meaning the companies must now respond to detailed allegations of coordinated production cuts and pricing decisions. The move comes as plaintiffs argue the firms simultaneously shifted resources toward high-margin HBM while throttling standard DDR4 output, coinciding with a roughly 700% price surge for conventional DRAM over 18 months.

How the alleged collusion works

Plaintiffs allege a coordinated strategy that began in late 2022, when the three firms reportedly refused to sign new long-term conventional DRAM deals and collectively tightened output across fabs. By steering customers toward higher-margin HBM and rationing standard memory, the firms allegedly created artificial scarcity, allowing them to raise prices without competing on cost or volume. Samsung, SK hynix and Micron have denied any wrongdoing and say they will defend themselves.

Who feels the squeeze

The impact is broad. Consumers buying laptops, gaming PCs and smartphones have faced higher component costs, which manufacturers have passed through to retail prices. Gaming platforms and console makers have reported cost increases tied to semiconductor shortages, and data-center operators relying on conventional DRAM have seen higher procurement expenses. The three firms collectively control more than 91% of the global DRAM market, giving them outsized leverage to set supply levels and pricing.

What happens next

The next concrete milestone is a deadline for the defendants to file their responses, set for 7 December 2026. A case management conference on 12 January 2027 will then determine the scope of discovery and any protective orders. Until then, the companies must defend whether their strategic shift to HBM and refusal to expand conventional capacity constitutes illegal collusion. If the court proceeds to discovery, internal emails, production reports and contract terms could reveal how closely the firms coordinated their output decisions.

Timeline of key dates

Date Event
Late 2022 Alleged start of coordinated supply restriction and HBM prioritisation
2022–2025 Roughly 700% price surge for conventional DRAM over 18 months
June 2025 Class-action lawsuit filed against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron
2026 Judge refuses to dismiss the lawsuit
7 December 2026 Deadline for defendants to file responses
12 January 2027 Case management conference to set discovery scope

If discovery proceeds, we may see evidence of shared customer vetting processes and coordinated production cuts. The eventual outcome could force them to unwind certain pricing practices or increase conventional DRAM capacity, but any such relief is unlikely before the trial itself. The court’s decision means the companies must now respond to detailed allegations of coordinated conduct and supply restriction.

Explore more coverage on BeansSearch this story across publishers